Age alone does not decide whether a roof needs replacing. Plenty of older roofs have years left, and some newer ones fail early after a bad storm or a poor install.
Signs a repair will do
A few missing or creased shingles, a leak around one vent or chimney, or damaged flashing in one spot. If the rest of the roof lies flat and holds its granules, a repair is usually the better spend.
Signs it is time to replace
Granules collecting in the gutters across the whole roof, curling or cracked shingles on several slopes, soft spots when someone walks the deck, or leaks in more than one place.
Get an honest second look
If one roofer says replace and you are not sure, ask another listed company for an inspection. Ask both to show you photos of what they found, slope by slope.
