Two quotes for the same roof can look far apart, and the gap is rarely the shingles. It is usually what each roofer included, left out or priced as an extra once the old roof is off.
Line up the same items
Put the quotes side by side and check each one for tear-off and disposal, decking repair priced per sheet, underlayment type, drip edge, flashing, vents and the permit. A quote that skips a line is not cheaper. It just moves that cost to a change order.
Ask how surprises are priced
Rotted decking only shows up after tear-off. A good quote states a price per sheet up front, so you know what a bad surprise costs before you sign.
Check what the warranty covers
Manufacturer warranties cover the material. The roofer's own warranty covers the installation, and that is the one you need a local company to stand behind.
For full price ranges by material, roof size and city, plus a calculator, see RoofReplacementCost.org.
